|
Geetings Mr. Chairman and Health
Committee Members,
My name is Joanne Cacciatore-Garard. I come to you today in
hopes of securing your support for an very important piece of legislation
for women and their families.
In 1892, American Author and Philosopher, Mark Twain said, “Favored
above Kings and Emperors is the stillborn child.” I wish that stillbirth
and the experience of having to deliver a dead baby was respected
in this manner back in 1994 when my fullterm baby girl died during
childbirth.
(Tell my personal
experience with Cheyenne’s death here—)
This tragedy
strikes everywhere. According to the Center for Positive Outcomes
in Pregnancy in Washington DC, there are 39K stillbirths in the
US every year. In 1999, there were more than 600 in Arizona. This
has affected our neighbors, my husband’s friends within the fire
dept, even your fellow legislators. Historically, we share this
horrific experience with John Quincy Adams, Rutherford Hayes, Ernest
and Pauline Hemingway, and John and Jackie Kennedy, whose stillborn
daughter is buried with her parents and siblings.
Dr. John DeFrain
of the Univ of Nebraska did an intensive research study of stillbirth
in the early 80’s. Many of the hundreds of participants expressed
deep pain and anxiety about the lack of validation for the experience
of birth. I asked myself while re-reading this study the other day,
“Why didn’t they do anything about it then?”
I don’t know.
But here I stand before you today, asking you to make this right.
Childbirth is
a unique physiological experience for women. It is such an important
event that we celebrate it every year in a ritual called the ‘birthday.’
Suzanne Arms, internationally acclaimed author and photojournalist
said of childbirth: Birth is an inherently successful process that
is a major social, economic, political, spiritual, and environmental
issue
Ask any woman
why she would endure the pain and agony of giving birth and she
will tell you because of the ‘reward’ at the end…it is ‘all worth
it,’ we frequently hear. But what about the silent births- the women
who get no reward for all their hard work…
Arizona, as all
other states in the US, currently issues the “Certificate of Fetal
Death” for stillborn infants. This document is a cruel and oppressive
reminder of a woman’s failure to produce a healthy living baby.
Women who endure stillbirth must still give birth- a physiological
process that includes great physical pain, incalculable emotional
investment, postpartum symptomology, and financial sacrifice.
We are asking
you to change this. Women deserve a birth certificate for their
babies. Other countries such as Australia, New Zealand, Norway,
Canada, and Ireland currently issue birth certificates for stillborns.
It is time for the United States to join these countries in their
support of women.
HB2416 is the
right thing to do for Arizona women and their families. It is a
change long overdue. We cannot issue merely a death certificate
to the women who give birth to stillborns. The birth, too, must
be acknowledged in a compassionate and sympathetic way. This is
the right and just thing to do. And as Martin Luther King, Jr. said,
“It is always the right time to do the right thing.”
|